Terms, conditions, and state restrictions apply. See SoFi.com/eligibility for details. SoFi loans are originated by SoFi Lending Corp., Licensed by the Departament of Business Oversight under the California Financing Law License. *https://www.sofi.com/legal#welcome-bonus

There’s nothing more welcoming than a warm and functional kitchen. Be it the whiff of fresh bread from the oven, the comfortable chit-chat of loved ones around a kitchen island, or the cozy dinners. If you’re contemplating a kitchen remodeling or are designing a new one, choosing the perfect countertop for this space is of paramount importance. So, in the selection between butcher block vs granite countertops, which one will you go for? In this article, we will make the choice easier for you by citing all the pros and cons.

Both have certain advantages as well as disadvantages. While butcher block is cheaper and requires easier installation, the granite one costs more and can be installed only by a professional. But, granite scores when it comes to a chic, trendy look; the butcher block looks a tad too traditional. Granite is prone to cracks while butcher block is more durable and can be refinished easily.

But, both do share a few similarities. Both are hugely popular, utilitarian, food safe, and fantastic to look at. They are convenient and practical. And, eco-friendly too! We do tend to gravitate towards the traditional charm of a butcher block countertop though. It’s warm and inviting. But since we’ve promised to give you an unbiased comparison, that is exactly what we’ll do.  

Granite CountertopPixabay

This article gives you a complete lowdown regarding both types. You can then choose the ideal kitchen countertop for your home. In fact, you may use the same parameters for your bathroom remodeling too.   

Butcher Block Vs Granite Countertops Costs

The price of a butcher block per se is around $1,000 to $1,500 for a kitchen that needs 30 square feet of it. The cost will of course depend upon the wood species used and the style of the countertop.

The whole installation will cost more, anything between $1,400 and $1,900. For instance, the labor cost may be approximately $250, and the sealant and other material may set you back by $70 to $90. And if the process includes an additional fabrication to match the cabinetry — that adds a few more dollars to the total cost.

Granite costs a lot more. Its cost per square foot is anything between $30 to, believe it or not, $500. The installation, that must only be done by a professional, is costlier too. It includes edging (generally $10 per linear foot), fabrication, and sink installation.

Cutouts of stainless steel sinks are around $100 a piece. As a standard kitchen size has 30 square feet of counter space, the total cost will be approximately $3,500, or even more.  

The Installation

butcher block countertopPixabay

Since wood countertops weigh a lot less than granite, installing a butcher block is a bit easier. However, they do require proper support at the bottom in terms of blocking. You don’t want a rickety countertop, do you?

They also need to be sealed and treated properly for them to last long and serve you well. Most homeowners also go for extra fabrication so that the countertops match the cabinets.   

Granite ones are heavier and require customized fabrication. Only a skilled professional can install such a countertop. The stone needs to be cut and fitted perfectly with the cabinets — complete with a sink cut-out. You need the exact measurements to make sure the granite fits perfectly.

Even cupboards may need to be reinforced before installation due to the heavy weight of the material. Apart from this, the epoxy has to be cured properly too. The process is a tad tedious but nothing a trained personnel can’t take care of.     

The Looks

If you like the traditional warmth of the kitchens of yesteryears — go for butcher block countertops. They have a rustic charm that’s undeniable. Walnut, cherry, maple, mixed wood, or birch — the options are many.

But, there’s a downside to the simplistic beauty that these offer — when it comes to reselling your house, the look might not add any resale value.

Granite countertops on the other hand look chic, trendy, and super-smooth. The color or design choice is almost endless. In fact, even a single stone is different from the other — thanks to the unique composition of minerals. If you like personalized, different-looking kitchens, go for this one. Each stone is beautifully uneven. Beautifully unique.

Read more: 7 White Kitchen Countertops for a Dreamy Kitchen

The Durability Quotient

Since wood needs to be safeguarded against water and sharp objects, this kind of countertop has to be treated with protectants such as specialized mineral oils from time to time. Unfortunately, the surface has the ability to hold onto water and this may cause it to be disfigured over time.

You must be careful not to let any water spillage be on the counter for long. And, also make sure to treat and refinish it regularly. Once you take care of this aspect, the thick wood is quite durable — it doesn’t even scratch easily.  

Granite too is scratch-and-stain-resistant. However, sharp knives and other blunt items may easily mar the surface. And, once the damage is done, it’s done. There is nothing much you can do in terms of filling the scratch or gouge.

Granite is also prone to cracks in the surface. Do ensure that any liquid spillage is cleaned up immediately. If it goes into the cracks, it may lead to discoloration or even bacterial growth.

The Ease Of Usage

The best part about a butcher block countertop is that it’s a chef’s delight. Chopping, preparation of food can be done right on the counter. Say goodbye to cutting boards! And this surface is easy to clean too.

If you’re not comfortable with prepping food all over the place, you can install a smaller portion of butcher block in your kitchen. For instance, on the island or just on top of a cabinet — a designated area for chopping and mixing. The rest of it can be granite, quartz countertop, or a laminate countertop.

Butcher Block Vs Granite CountertopsPhoto by Designbuildinhabit on Flickr licensed under CC BY-ND 2.0

On a granite top, you may prepare food but chopping is a big no-no. As explained earlier, a knife can easily scratch the surface. Any damage will then be impossible to repair.

But, there is some good news, these counters are heat-resistant and quite sanitary if sealed properly. With correct care and maintenance, they will last you a lifetime — adding value to your home.

Read more: Quartz Vs Granite Countertops: The Pros And Cons

Summary

Now that you’ve analyzed some vital differences between both kinds of countertops, you will know which one to use for your home improvement. let’s make it easier for you by giving you a summary.

Butcher Block Countertops

PROS

  • Traditional look
  • Cheaper price
  • Easy installation
  • Great for direct chopping
  • Perfect for a sustainable environment

CONS

  • Needs regular treatment/ refinishing
  • Not fully water or heat-resistant
  • Limited colors and wood species
  • A tad outdated

Granite Countertops

PROS

  • Beautiful, chic to look at
  • Modern
  • Lots of color, pattern options
  • Has unique variations
  • Durable
  • Heat-and-water resistant

CONS

  • Expensive 
  • Installation only by a professional, time-consuming
  • Measurements can’t be even slightly inaccurate
  • Needs regular sealing
  • Scratches easily with sharp objects
  • Impossible to improve in parts

We’re sure, you’re no longer scratching your head when it comes to the dilemma of butcher block vs granite countertops. You can evaluate both, using the parameters we mentioned. This article made it easy for you, didn’t it? We’re always happy to help.

Read more: Quartz vs Marble Countertops: Pros and Cons

Butcher Block vs Granite Countertops: Which Is Best for Your Kitchen? was last modified: July 17th, 2019 by Ramona Sinha
contact

Need a Contractor?

Get contractors to call you back

Pick a pro for me